Did you miss the beginning of the story? Catch up with parts 1, 2, and 3.
Oh yes, he kissed me.
He kissed me like he meant it. As the song says, “He kissed me in a way that I’ve never been kissed before.” He kissed me like he had been waiting quite some time to do so. We talked, and kissed, and talked some more for what felt like hours (both giddy from the situation) before I snuck into Katie’s room for the night.
The next morning, I woke up with one thought in my mind...
Oh CRAP.
Crap.
What have I DONE?!
I was suddenly questioning everything that had happened the night before. Was I too brazen? What was I thinking? What if Mitch was totally embarrassed and didn’t want to be around me any more? What if I had ruined my friendship with Katie?
Slowly, cautiously, I rolled out of Katie’s bed and freshened up, brushing my teeth and grimacing from my hangover. Then I decided to face the music and head into the main room where Katie and Mitch were watching tv.
I looked out and, as tentatively as a field mouse, said “good morning”.
Silence.
Oh crap.
I retreated back into the bedroom, mind reeling. “I can’t believe they didn’t even say good morning. Katie must be furious. Mitch is embarrassed, he probably feels attacked. How could I just pounce on him like that?!” Then, I started thinking more rationally. “Wait a minute, this is ridiculous! I know I didn’t imagine that chemistry…”
After a few minutes of high-anxiety-fretting, I knew I had to face them again. I walked back into the living room, cleared my throat, and, a little more loudly this time, said “Good Morning.” They both turned to me and smiled, saying good morning in response. Crisis Averted!
(I later learned that they hadn’t heard me the first time, hence my momentary panic).
So, I felt better now, but I still wasn’t sure where things stood. I wondered if Mitch had said anything to Katie, whether Katie remembered that I had told her I liked her brother, and whether or not I could make a fast escape without being too obvious.
Where did I stand with Mitch? Did he like me? How was I going to be able to talk to him alone without Katie getting suspicious? I decided to play it by ear and after packing up my things the stars aligned and I had a moment alone with him.
Mitch was lying on the couch, watching tv, and I touched his hand gently and asked if it would be okay if I called him later that week. He said, “sure” (he never has been a man of many words) and then I said goodbye and walked out the door.
On the drive home, I replayed every moment. Could I have imagined the chemistry between us? Surely he had enjoyed that kiss… Oh my, that kiss. My heart started to do flip flops as I replayed the previous night in my mind & debated my options.
Katie was heading home to Ohio that evening for Christmas break and Mitch would be home alone for almost a week. If there was ever a time to make a move, this was it. I’d be able to go on a date with him (presuming he wanted to of course!) and see if there was any chemistry when it was just the two of us… no alcohol involved.
In fact, Katie didn’t even need to know about it. If we went on a few dates and things didn’t work out, we could just amicably part ways and still remain friends. There wouldn’t be as much weirdness if Katie didn’t know in the first place.
So I had a plan; and two days later I called him to see if he wanted to go on a date. As the phone started to ring, my insides were churning. Would he want to see me again? Was I doing the right thing? Would he be okay with keeping things secret from Katie for a few days?
Would he answer the phone?
To be continued